← All posts

Applying for Australia from the UK on points? What new research says the test gets wrong

Visa guide · 2026-09-03 · 4 min read

If you are thinking of emigrating to Australia from the UK without an employer behind you, the points test is the gatekeeper. It decides who is invited to apply for permanent residence on a skilled visa. New research that matched tax, Census and visa records over three decades suggests it is not very good at picking the people who go on to do well, and it sets out two ways it could be fixed.

Nothing here has changed the rules yet. These are research findings and reform options, but they show where the debate is heading.

Who actually uses the points test now

The test was designed decades ago for a typical applicant living overseas and starting from scratch. That is no longer the main user. Most points-tested visas now go to people who are already in Australia, many of them former international students moving from a study visa towards residence.

Alongside them is a large and growing group stuck on bridging and temporary visas. That uncertainty is hard on the people involved and adds strain to housing, public services and infrastructure that were never planned around it.

Criteria that score points but do not predict success

Researchers compared tax outcomes with visa pathways from the early 2010s to 2022. Several of the things that earn points showed little or no link to how migrants actually fared, and a few were linked to worse results:

• community language credentials
• studying in a regional area
• professional year programmes
• specialist qualifications outside the core regulated fields
• having studied at an Australian university

The student route came out especially poorly. People who arrived on a student visa and later went through the points system tend to earn less and are much more likely to work below their qualification level than those who came by other routes.

Three deeper problems

The research argues this is more than a matter of adjusting a few numbers:

1. The weighting is off. Age, education, English and relevant work experience have strong evidence behind them but count for less than they should, while weaker criteria still earn points.
2. One scale for every job. The same scoring works fairly well in regulated professions such as healthcare, where a qualification maps neatly onto a job, but poorly in areas like engineering and business, where contacts, local hiring habits and fit matter more.
3. Useful evidence is ignored. People already working in Australia are scored on the same paper criteria as first-time applicants overseas, even though there are years of real earnings data on them.

The two reform options

Streamline the current test. Remove the categories with no predictive value and give more weight to age, education, English and Australian work experience. This is the easier option to bring in: a recalibration rather than a redesign, but still a real improvement.

Split it into two streams. The more ambitious option, with a bigger potential payoff. Applicants would be separated by whether they are already working in Australia: a skills-based stream for overseas applicants and recent graduates not yet working locally, and a labour-market-experience stream for temporary visa holders already employed in their nominated occupation.

In the split model, the skills-based stream would be a traditional points test weighted towards age, education and English, focused on occupations where newcomers without local experience do find skilled work, largely regulated fields such as medicine. The experience stream would look mainly at age and proven Australian earnings over the previous two years, much like employer sponsorship but with the flexibility of points.

Where a UK applicant would fit

Most people applying from the UK would fall into the skills-based stream, so the traits it favours are worth noting: age, education and English. On English, many Australian work visas accept a current UK passport as meeting the language requirement; check your visa's page on the Home Affairs English language page. The research also points to regulated occupations as the strongest route for applicants from overseas, which suits UK nurses and other registered professionals.

If you would rather prove yourself in work first, a sponsored role is the other way in. You can browse sponsored jobs in Australia for British workers while the points debate plays out.

#points test #skilled visas #australia #permanent residence #visa reform #emigrate to australia